You may or may not have known that for the past two years I have been an Agnostic. I affirmed a higher power in life, but did not know or understand what that power was. The following is an account of how I came to become an agnostic, and how those two years were essential in order to discover God and affirm Jesus Christ as Lord.
I grew up in a Christian home. While we may not have all gone to church together every Sunday, by the time I was in junior high, Church had become a habit ingrained in my lifestyle. My whole life was based around the Church. I made all of my closest friends at Church. I met my mentor at a Young Life camp. I made even more friends at Young Life. Everything I did in my social life was based on the calendar of Church and Young Life. I committed my life to Jesus in 8th grade. When you’re that age, you are forced to create an identity very rapidly, and there just isn’t enough time to fully develop who you are when life happens. In the rush to create my identity, I let the Church create me. The youth pastors and leaders told us to have Jesus at the base of our identity. That’s what I thought I was doing, but instead of pursuing Jesus, I pursued Christianity
In High School, the way I understood one ought to live their life is as a Christian. I wanted to be a good person, so I did my best to be a good Christian. I volunteered at every avenue I could. I was leading small groups at Church and playing drums in the worship band. All the while unhealthy psychological tendencies were developing deep inside my heart. But I ignored them. I didn’t have time to worry about myself; I had to prepare what my small group was going to read that night. If I was going to do things well, I had to be a good Christian, so I went through all the motions of what a Christian does, except for the essential part-a relationship with Jesus Christ. I did everything else though, I read my bible, I went to every church event I could, and I was damn good at the Popcorn Prayer. I thought I was pursuing God, but really I was trying to live the way a Christian ought to live, and along the way my concept of God had been skewed by immature high school insecurities.
I was doing my best to be a good Christian. I thought early on that to be a good Christian you had to pursue God-that is correct, but that made me wrongly assume that everything secular was secondhand. I thought a good Christian was only interested in things that were related to Church. All other passions were second rate, secular, and were of no concern to a Christian. This created a huge conflict within me. While I wanted to be a good Christian, I also had a passion for the movies. Whenever I caught myself thinking about going into the world of Cinema, I told myself it was a pipe dream. “God doesn’t want you involved in fantasies like filmmaking,” I thought. “Pursue God: that is your only duty.” So I bit my lip and repressed my passion for film as best I could.
So when it came time to pick a college, Whitworth, a small Christian university, was the obvious choice. I believed that a good Christian ought to be a pastor, because that career is the only one that pursues God. I didn’t understand how only some of us at Whitworth wanted a theology degree; I thought it was the only one that’s worth it, since it was our duty to follow God and God alone. Meanwhile, my other lingering career aspiration had been clawing for attention. It was getting to be too much. I had to do away with my passion for film. I knew that you were supposed to follow God, but I didn’t know how I could do that in the movies, I couldn’t reconcile my passion for movies and my need to follow God. So I thought the reason I had a passion for film was so I could sacrifice it in order to follow God. Jesus talked about taking up your cross and sacrificing your life in order to follow him. So at the time, I understood that to mean we need to kill things that we were most passionate about in order to follow God. And yet, I could never kill that passion. I hated myself for failing.
The other great passion I struggled with was Women. In high school and college, I had really bad luck with dating. For some reason I was just having a tougher time than my friends. I wasn’t meeting the right girl, and I thought there was something seriously wrong with me. Since I wasn’t finding anyone, and since I was getting so upset about it, I didn’t have any other option but to somehow put away this passion for women, which I needed to do in terms of God. So like film, I felt God expected me to sacrifice having a girl in my life. I felt that I was supposed to accept being alone in order to follow God. I felt that my passion for women must have been sinful, that my attraction to woman was only because of my depraved nature, and any attraction was just lust. I had to get over women in order to follow God. I hated myself for failing.
By my junior year at Whitworth, I was burnt out on church with heavily repressed desires that made me hate myself. Eventually, I couldn’t hold out any longer, and so I gave into my desire for film. I switched majors from Theology to English at the end of my sophomore year. And in my new pursuit of film, it felt good, it felt right, more right than God. That feeling scared me. God was supposed to fill me with joy, so why was film doing a much better job?
That made me think about how I was raised, how I went to church all of my life and how it rapidly shaped my identity, all of it happening behind the scenes of my consciousness. I realized that I had given up control of what I believed, and really, I never had much control to begin with. I realized that from the day I was born, the outside world had a profound impact on who I was. The world shaped my personality and my characteristics. It was the world that taught me the conception of truth and being raised in the church created a bias to name Christ as Lord. My liberty was at the mercy of the world that created me, and it would be years until I realize the potency of the world’s power over my freewill.
Since I never was fully conscious of my choosing God, that my childhood had created a bias previously unknown, I realized that my belief was inauthentic and mostly fake. My conception of God had been skewed by my history of insecurity, chiefly my insecurities about cinema and women. The real God wanted to be discovered. I knew that my faith was phony, and the only way to find God was to tear down everything I knew about God, question everything and build up an authentic belief from the ground up. A part of me knew at the time that it was God who told me to be an agnostic. Ironic.
So I tore down my faux-Christian identity, and life got a lot happier. I pursued art and embraced its power to influence and inspire my life. I talked to people I would usually ignore as a Christian. I understood what they were most passionate about. I realized how authentic other atheists and agnostics were. I started preferring their company to other Christians because they seemed real, they didn’t sound like clones. Don’t get me wrong, I still loved my Christian friends, it’s just the agnostics weren’t afraid to express that which was most precious in their heart, they were real, and sometimes painfully so.
And so I was happy, so I stopped worrying about God. Apathy was the name of the game. I would go weeks without thinking about God. Why would I? I was learning about the passion of humanity in the arts, so why would I go back to the frozen chosen languishing in the pews, ultimately nurturing loneliness and unhappiness?
The only reminder I got about God was from my friend Sara. We would enjoy philosophical debates in coffee shops. Eventually God came up, and I simply stated that I didn’t care. She insisted that I should. But I couldn’t. She was like that friend who was trying to convince you how amazing the movie you just saw really was. Try as they might, you just weren’t moved by it. It’s not that you thought the movie was bad; it just wasn’t as good as “Blade Runner”.
Yet she persisted. I don’t know where she got the willpower, but she kept bringing Him up. Apathy was hard to explain to her. I acknowledged his existence, so why didn’t I care about his wanting to be in my life? She had me there—damn women, I hate it when they’re right.
But I knew that I had to respect the agnostic process. I know that sounds lazy and pretentious, but I had a lot of work to do so that I could fathom God’s being. Picture it like this, in order to rediscover God; I had to come to him afresh, to see him from the farthest out so that I could slowly take all of him in. It’s like a rocket ship that wants to rediscover the magnificence of Earth. In order to do that, it needs to orbit around the dark side of the Moon, and return to the Earth, afresh. Sara was calling me back to Earth; but I knew I had to reach the moon first. And what was on the moon? My insecurities. It was those insecurities that contributed to the false conception of God. In order to come home to God, to prepare a slate ready to understand the real God, I would have to understand the issues that plagued my soul.
At the end of my sophomore year I switched majors from Theology to English. We don’t have a film program at Whitworth so I did English literature. I fell in love with reading, and my knowledge and understanding of not only film but all the arts had been heightened. I watched an embarrassing amount of films in the past two years. I think for an entire month I watched at least one film a day. Roger Ebert recently said that "the movies, as they always do, will cheer and inspire me. They heal, because they take me into the minds of their creators.” I couldn’t say it any better. The movies affirmed my passion for not only beauty, but my need to know the person behind it. There are certain filmmakers who have the incredible ability to light up the screen with awe and wonder, it is my belief that that talent is from God alone. I know now that film is an inspired passion of mine. The world of cinema is where I belong. My two years of agnosticism confirmed that passion.
Once I became an agnostic, I realized that I was actually damn handsome, and that any woman should be lucky enough to be pursued by me. But it took all two years to come to that understanding. I didn’t really go crazy once I unshackled myself from the rules of Christianity. When I came to Portland, I could have been that guy at the bar who constantly hit on women and had a bunch of one-night stands. But I knew deep in my heart that that is not what I wanted, and I knew it wasn’t the after effects of Christianity; it really was something I believed in. It was my agnosticism that allowed me to understand that. The Church can instill fear in young men. In high school, I hated myself for failing in my romantic pursuits, so I convinced myself that all of my romantic emotions were the product of lust, and therefore sin. It was the only justification I could make for myself and only now I realize how psychologically damaging that is. But I came to understand myself as a passionate and sensitive man when it came to romance-whether it was by how I was raised or something deeply innate about me, I knew that my potential to love a woman was not lust, not sin, but something so right. My conflicted nature was the reason for my failure in romance-fear, insecurity, and no confidence in myself was why I failed-not because of a sadistic God who commanded worship without end.
I always told Sara that it had to be God that was the motivation to return to Him. A part of me wanted to be a Christian again so I could find someone to date. But I didn’t want loneliness to motivate me. Know this dear reader, being an agnostic is a lonely time. You are always a stranger in a strange land. There is not one group you’re fully apart of, not even other agnostics, because you’re all in very different boats. So I waited out the loneliness and discovered myself. I discovered the beauty of solitude. In my time with myself I affirmed everything that was in the core of my heart, without worrying about religion or spirituality. And so I discovered my passion and the love of myself. I was always lonely, but never truly alone. I learned to be alone but not lonely. I learned about the power of art and its ability to illuminate the soul. I learned about my potential as a person. And it excites me to think about my potential as an artist.
And so at the end of two years, I learned about the important things in my life that I freely chose and affirmed. Without worrying about the law of God, or pleasing God with a high moral code, I understood that life amounted to this: That we have been born as people who ought to live in community together, who do their best to love themselves and to love others in every way that is most right, and to pursue the passionate things found deepest in their heart. For me, to live is to express those things deepest within my heart, that being love, truth, and passion. It is my need to love my family, love my friends, and to find a special woman to fall madly in love with.
So in the midst of my life affirming self realization, I discovered the life I wanted, and I realized, it was the life that God wanted for me, and behind it all, I discovered God. God had shown me the life he wants me to live, and he has shown me that he is meant to be at the center of it all. That doesn’t mean a life of religion but a pursuit of the life God has promised: Life to the full. I know that it was God who told me to pursue agnosticism. In those two years I discovered how to love myself and the things I wanted to do. Now that I know that, I understand that God has made me who I am. He created me with certain tendencies and allowed me to be born at a certain time, in a certain place, to a certain family. He will use me through the things I do.
I don’t live like I did in high school. Back then, everything outside of the church was secular, second rate. Now I know that God is bigger than the institutions we made for him. The parts of life that are filled with truth and passion are because of God. I forgot religiousness and discovered a spiritual life. By pursuing God, I pursue myself, I know the life that I have is a gift from God, and I know God has great plans for me. To accomplish them, I follow God, the God of the universe who created all of us who were made to live a life to the full.